Can a pH Probe Detect Negative pH?

can-ph-probe-detect-negative-ph

Share This Post

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit
Share on linkedin
Share on email

Negative pH is possible, however, whether an acidic solution actually has a negative pH is not something that can easily be determined in a lab, therefore you cannot accurately measure/detect negative pH values with a pH probe. 

A pH probe is used to detect the potential hydrogen (pH), which has a usual range from 0-14. Measuring pH tells us how much hydrogen is in a substance, usually a liquid, like water. It can also tell us how active a hydrogen ion is.  A solution with a high amount of hydrogen-ion activity is an acid. In contrast, a solution with a high amount of hydroxide ion activity is a base. 

Using pH probes when measuring pH is important for a wide range of industries, which is why there are different pH sensors for different applications.

Can You Detect A Negative pH?

While the pH scale typically runs from 0 to 14, it is definitely possible to calculate a negative pH. A negative pH occurs when the molarity of hydrogen ions in a strong acid is greater than 1 N (Normality). You can calculate a negative pH when an acid solution yields a concentration of hydrogen ions with molarity greater than 1.

For example, the pH of 12M HCl (hydrochloric acid) is calculated like this:

pH = -log[H+]

pH = -log[12]

pH = -1.08

By all means, calculating a negative pH is not the same as a solution being measured with a pH probe, and actually having a negative pH.

Using a pH probe to detect negative pH is not very accurate, since there are no standards for very low pH values. The majority of the inaccuracy comes from the large potential developed at the liquid junction of the reference electrode inside the pH probe. 

Even though many textbooks may state that a negative pH is possible using a pH probe, no examples are given. This is probably as negative pH values cannot be easily measured or determined in a lab, and the poor availability of buffer standards suitable for a pH <1

Negative pH & The Dissociation Of Ions

Another point we should mention is the dissociation of ions. 

Despite commonly calculating hydrochloric acid this way, the above pH equation for HCl is not accurate, as it presumes a complete dissociation of ions has taken place inside the strong acid solution. 

But, we must take into account that the hydrogen ion activity is generally higher in a concentrated strong acid compared to a more dilute solution. This is due to the solution containing a low concentration of water per unit of acid. 

Because stronger acids cannot fully dissociate in water at higher concentrations when measuring the pH of HCl with a pH probe, some hydrogen ions would remain bound to the chlorine atoms, and therefore the true pH value would be higher than the calculated pH.

To understand negative pH, we must work out whether the incomplete dissociation of ions or an increased hydrogen ion activity has a greater effect. If the increased hydrogen ion activity has a greater effect, the acid is likely to have a negative pH value.

How To Measure Negative pH

As previously mentioned, experimentally detecting negative pH values is a little complicated. 

You cannot measure a negative pH value with a pH probe, nor is there a special pH litmus paper that turns a specific color when a negative pH is detected. 

So, if litmus paper doesn’t work, then why cannot we just dip a pH probe into a solution like HCl? 

Well, if you were to place a commercial glass pH electrode (probe) into HCl and measure the negative pH, it would be subject to significant errors, usually displaying an “acid error” to the reader. This error causes the pH probe to measure a higher pH than the real pH value of HCl. A glass pH probe that gives this high reading cannot be corrected to obtain the true pH value of solutions such as HCl. 

When a negative pH is detected in a real-world situation, special correction factors are applied to the pH probe measurements. The two methods frequently used to scale these measurements are known as “The Pitzer approach and MacInnes assumption”. 

The Pitzer approach to a solution’s ion concentration is widely accepted to estimate single-ion activity coefficients, and to understand the MacInnes assumption, we can look at HCl. The MacInnes assumption states that the individual coefficients for an aqueous solution such as H+ and Cl- are equal

Examples Of Negative pH Environments

Negative pH can be found from natural water acidic streams to mine drainage. 

The two most dominant sources of extremely low pH in natural waters are magmatic gasses (found in vents and crater lakes) and hot springs . 

Some examples of the lowest pH values currently reported in environmental samples are:

  • Hot springs near Ebeko Volcano, Russia: pH = -1.7
  • Fumarolic condensates (HCl-HF) from Kilauea Iki, Hawaiʻi : pH = -0.3
  • Lake waters from Poás crater, Costa Rica: pH = -0.89
  • The acidic crater lake of Kawah Ijen, Java, Indonesia: pH = 0.02-0.2

Conclusion

Negative pH is possible, however, whether or not an acidic solution actually has a negative pH is not something that can easily be determined in a lab, therefore you cannot accurately measure extremely low pH values with a commercial glass pH electrode. 

It is also difficult to use a pH to detect if the pH of a solution is lowered by the increase of hydrogen ion activity or via incomplete dissociation. To measure extremely low pH values, special electrodes would have to be used that incorporate special correction factors, which is why negative pH is currently calculated and not detected.

If you have any questions regarding pH, or what pH probes we have to offer, do not hesitate to contact our world-class team at Atlas Scientific

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get product updates and learn from the best!

More To Explore

is-acidic-water-bad-for-you
Blog

Is Acidic Water Bad For You?

It is not recommended to drink acidic water because of the high concentration of heavy metals and potentially dangerous health effects such as tooth decay and bone loss. Water that has a low pH can also damage your plumbing system, leaching metals into your water supply.  To determine if water is acidic, alkaline, or neutral,

what-makes-water-acidic
Blog

What Makes Water Acidic?

Carbon dioxide is the most common cause of acidic water, however, anthropogenic (human-induced) pollution which causes acid rain, can also make the water acidic.  When water becomes acidic, it is very corrosive, and when water becomes corrosive, it can damage plumbing systems, costing water industries millions of dollars in repair costs. Acidic water can also

Want to learn more about our products?

Scroll to Top

To track your order please enter your Order ID in the box below and press the "Track" button. This was given to you on your receipt and in the confirmation email you should have received.